Slightly Out of Focus

How independent is independent?

VS Engineering, Inc., of Indianapolis, has been retained by the town ''as an independent engineering firm to evaulate the proposed plans for adherence to normal design standards for road and bridge projects.''

Specifically, the firm was hired to discuss current plans to replace Boone County bridge 220 - the Ford Road bridge over Eagle Creek.

The plans to replace the bridge with an historic steel truss span has been ongoing for longer than the gestation period of an elephant.

In a memorandum to the Boone County Commissioners from Tim Haak, Zionsville Town Council president, dated April 12, in reference to the named bridge, it states:

''The Zionsville Town Council has reviewed the proposed design and has arrived at the following conclusion.

The Town Council objects to the project as a whole as currently presented. We are not comfortable with proposed treatment of several key design issues within minimum or less than minimum standards.''

The memo cites four ''main concerns.''

A committee composed of County Commissioner Mark Applegate, Robert Clutter, county attorney; Haak and Elizabeth Hopper, town councilors and VS Engineering. met March 22 to discuss plans to replace the bridge. There is no reference in Haak's memo who represented the engineering firm.

But Zionsville Confidential knows VS Engineering.

The president of VS Engineering is Sanjay Patel, who was a member of the group which assisted in developing the Zionsville Master Transportation Plan last year.

Mr. Patel, a resident of Zionsville, is also a member of the Zionsville Storm Water Board, and his firm has a contract for the redesign of First Street in Zionsville.

A real cozy relationship.

What also raised eyebrows is the question of when the Zionsville Town Council took this action, as stated in Haak's April 12 memo:

''The Zionsville Town Council has reviewed the proposed design and has arrived at the following conclusions.''

That sounds as though the council had a meeting and formulated a position, but there are questions about when a meeting was held, and was it public?

The folks who have been instrumental in bringing the historic span to Eagle Creek might do well to ask to see the minutes of the meeting when the Zionsville council made the decision on the bridge.